Skip to Content
Tier
Tier Your gaming journal
Get
Community

Video game reviews of Red Dead Redemption

3 video game reviews published by the Tier community, each rated out of 10 and graded from F to S, tier-list style. One feed to spot masterpieces, letdowns and dissenting takes at a glance.

Red Dead Redemption
Filter
Reviews of Red Dead Redemption
Back to game page
Red Dead Redemption
Red Dead Redemption 2010
S 9.5

It's really weird how good this game is. The game isn't dragging, the story is very well told, the ending is absurdly good. The only thing that…

Translated from Portuguese

Red Dead Redemption
Red Dead Redemption 2010
A 8.5

What I liked: the music - the map at night - the ambient music + darker than 2

Translated from French

Red Dead Redemption
Red Dead Redemption 2010
S 10.0

Wow in 2025 on the remastered, what a pleasure

Translated from French

Advertisement

How do ratings work on Tier?

On Tier, every player rates a game out of 10, and that score translates into a tier-list grade: S for masterpieces (9 and up), A for excellent games (8+), B for great ones (6.5+), C for mixed experiences (5+), D for letdowns (3+) and F for failures. The grade gives the verdict at a glance, the score out of 10 adds the nuance. A review can also skip the rating and stand on text alone.